... when erudite, smart, and intelligent people write 18,999,453,111 words dissecting, defending, condemning, prejudging, and assigning motives to a very short story based on the title alone?
I wish I have the ability to gain that much insight just from looking at a few words on the cover.
The discussion would probably make some sense if some people who are busy talking take the trouble to actually read the short story, no, and figure out why the story is titled the way it is?
Otherwise it's like arguing what animal one sees forming among the clouds, no? Some say cat, another bunch say the clouds are shaped like a dog, and there will be no end to the "discussion".
File this drama under "Why reading comments in blogs can make my eyes roll upwards".